@7:15 the astronaut shoots the Doctor. It was the tesselecta. The Silence continues Moffat's trend of using simple psychological concepts to make his monsters more frightening. The Doctor finds the spaceship actually sits below the store, underground, accessed from the changing room. The first was simply a "stunt double" which did not have teeth and was meant for being thrown around or laid still. Thank you! [9][10] The Silence are perceived only while being viewed; they are instantly forgotten once a viewer looks away. But at this point she hasn't . In "The Day Of The Moon", while Ganger Amy is walking through the children's home, she sees some framed portraits of herself holding Melody. The problem wasnt that River did and then didnt kill the Doctor, it was that River did and didnt kill the Tesselecta. Later in the picnic, the earlier version of River Song in an Apollo spacesuit emerged from the lake and shot the Doctor three times, apparently killing him. Why did The Doctor start to regenerate at Lake Silencio? Doctor Who - Lake Silencio Fictional Travel Print wall art The Doctor manages to reverse the teleporter and disable it. However, Anders was bothered by the running joke of the Doctor and Craig being mistaken for a gay couple and the stereotypes the episode relied on, such as the "clueless dad" and the ignorant shop girls. Craig, struggling to care for Alfie alone while Sophie is away for the weekend, suspects the Doctor is investigating something alien. [27] Digital Spy's Morgan Jeffery praised Smith, Corden, and Lynda Baron as Val, and felt that it was a "relief" to have a fun episode after two emotional heavy ones. Throughout Doctor Who 's fifth, sixth, and seventh seasons, the mysterious Silence played a huge role in the background of the story. The Doctor tries to restore the universe with the help of River and the alternative universe versions of his companions Amy Pond (Karen Gillan) and Rory Williams (Arthur Darvill). The Doctor never revealed to Amy and Rory that he went out of regenerations (and maybe Moffat hadn't decided on that back then either), so it makes sense for them to see the Doctor attempting to regenerate. I agree that the Grand Moff set up an almost impossible scenario to wiggle out of. The Doctor prepares to leave, but he notices a strange electrical disturbance in the area and decides to investigate. Lake [5], The Silence shown in "The Impossible Astronaut" are depicted as tall humanoids with bulbous heads and mouthless, bony faces, partly inspired by Edvard Munch's The Scream. As to River missing: Who said she missed? [9] The skulls were hand-crafted and required a lot of preparation, so it was one of the first things started for the episode's production. We asked for help, but instead of rope and tow bars the campers only offered stories of how every day at least four or five cars get stuck in the sand here. Tiia was trying to hide her giggles. At one point I had the perverse notion that Kovarian might be a later regeneration of River Song, building a further time-loop layer on top of the story. He commented that it was a change of pace for Corden, who usually was cast as "the funny one"; as Craig he is "the straight man to the wacky Doctor". [10] Though most of the episode is intended to be fun, it also sets the stage for the finale and the Doctor's upcoming death. Change), You are commenting using your Facebook account. And looking that up turned up an image of Travis in an eyepatch and Stetson. Plot. Reddit's Doctor Who Fan Community - News, Discussion, Artwork and Fan Creations! The Doctor expresses his dislike for Craig's "redecorated" house by using a line from the Second Doctor (Patrick Troughton) in The Three Doctors (1973)[6] and The Five Doctors (1983). It cant be as simple as the Doctors name. In the episode, the archaeologist River Song (Alex Kingston) is programmed by the religious order the Silence to kill the alien time traveller the Doctor (Matt Smith) to prevent "the first question" from being asked on a planet called Trenzalore in the Doctor's future. The concept of petrichor was used as a psychic password in "The Doctor's Wife" and means "the smell of dust after rain". These Silence use the energy discharge from their hands to displace someone, leaving behind only debris in the form of ash like flakes. The evidence is equivocal. [6] McNeice felt there was room for his character to return, as "Victory of the Daleks" had hinted that he and the Doctor knew each other well. [20] Final consolidated figures by the Broadcasters' Audience Research Board were 7.67 million viewers, the seventh highest for BBC One and the second most-watched programme for 1 October. She fires five shots, all from pretty close range, and misses every time. The Doctor now finds himself on an Earth where all history is happening simultaneously . What would happen if Venus and Earth collided? The energy for regeneration comes from the Tardis. I dunno about favorite episode, I think The Wedding of River Song might be, but yes I think definately best season. I hadnt though of that. Though the Doctor's death at Lake Silencio was thought to be a "fixed point" of history, it turns out he faked his death, with River imprisoned for it so that the Silence will believe him dead. Amy runs towards him. Its flames were reflected in the water, licking away at the ripples surrounding it. Club Silencio, a fictional club in the 2001 film Mulholland Drive; Lake Silencio, a fictional lake in the Doctor Who episodes "The Impossible Astronaut" and "The Wedding of River Song" Silencio, a luchador character of Kenny Hotz; See also. [10] Director Steve Hughes compared the Doctor and Craig to famous comedic duos such as Laurel and Hardy, Abbott and Costello, and Simon Pegg and Nick Frost. The Silence reveal, however, that they have the power to remotely kill the devices' wearersas such, they betray Kovarian by killing her. [22], The episode received generally positive reviews, with critics praising the comic interplay between Smith and Corden. Why do microcontrollers always need external CAN tranceiver? Surely she cant have it both ways. Amy allows Kovarian to die as revenge for the kidnapping and brain-washing of her daughter Melody (aka River Song). However, she was critical of the reason River had to kill the Doctor as well as their relationship, and believed that Amy's killing Madame Kovarian was "no substitute" for Amy's dealing with what Kovarian had done to her child.[34]. Thats why when they kissed in the alternate reality it folded in the real event. Both the Doctor and River have it. Time moves forward and reality returns to normal. Users are free to select their physician of choice from among all Lifespan-affiliated medical staff physicians. He thought that the moments of "sad-eyed loneliness and resignation" added weight to "what would otherwise have been a paper-thin episode". ", "Are Doctor Who's latest aliens The Silence just too terrifying for words? "[27], Dave Golder of SFX gave the episode four-and-a-half out of five stars, explaining that he was in conflict whether to rate it five or four stars and calling it "about nine-tenths a great, great episode". Too late. [9], "The Wedding of River Song" was one of the last episodes filmed for the series; 29 April 2011 was the last day of filming. It also pays tribute to the classic series character Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart following the death of the character's actor Nicholas Courtney. In "The Wedding of River Song", many Silence appear in a parallel universe caused by River not shooting the Doctor. Most likely, since only the time lords knew about the War Doctor being "The Doctor" (he wasn't using the name since even he didn't count himself as "The Doctor"), and since almost no one knew about the "Meta-Crisis Doctor" that when they killed him, his enemies would expect a regeneration, so he had the Tesselecta produce the regeneration effect. Both they (and others involved with Audio Visuals) went on to work for the BBC on the official Doctor Who franchise, with Briggs becoming the programme's designated Dalek and Cyberman voice artiste, as well as appearing on screen in the Torchwood: Children of Earth miniseries. Their origins are eventually revealed in the 2013 special "The Time of the Doctor". Angelo DiCenso, MD | Lifespan Roberts and showrunner Steven Moffat wanted to bring Craig back, having enjoyed "The Lodger" and Corden's performance. Handed 12,000 life sentences for his murder, River spent her days at Stormcage Containment Facility, but her nights travelling with the Doctor.Born Melody Pond, to Amy Pond and Rory Williams during the Battle of Demon's Run, she was kidnapped by agents of The Silence and raised as the Doctor's perfect assassin. [28] IGN's Matt Risley rated "The Wedding of River Song" 8.5 out of 10, writing it "managed to tie together plot threads and character arcs without too much Deus Ex Maguffiny predictability and with a whole host of trademark sci-fi spectacle to boot". This is because the Cybermen from "Rise of the Cybermen" originated from a parallel universe, while the prime universe has its own Cybermen from the planet Mondas, as seen in the classic series. The long-overdue serious attempt at Lisp, part 2: is Lisp just too hard? Set after River's attempt at changing a fixed point and the Doctor inside the retells the events which took place, which include meeting the Teselecta again and acquiring it to travel inside. [6], One of the Silence calls Rory "the man who dies and dies again", a reference to the many times he appears to die. There was also that little teaser after the end credits of A good man goes to war with the skeletal hand holding a sonic screwdriver so i think there may be a possibility that we will see a Ganger Doctor. Likewise @5:54 Human beings. It only takes a minute to sign up. I actually did figure this out on my own shortly after writing the post in the comment here. [10], The Cybus Industries logo, which had been used on the Cybermen since their redesign for the revived series in "Rise of the Cybermen"/"The Age of Steel" (2006), was covered up for the Cybermen in this episode as well as the ones which had previously appeared in "A Good Man Goes to War". I have no idea what the question itself is. This will be important later. "The Wedding of River Song" is the thirteenth and final episode in the sixth series of the British science fiction television series Doctor Who, and was first broadcast on BBC One on 1 October 2011. There has to be more to it. It would make story sense, and it would be an admirably brave thing to do. They are partly inspired by mythological figures known as "men in black" that became popular amongst UFO conspiracy theorists during the 1950s and 60s,[7] as well as grey aliens. Whatever, I really enjoyed the episode, and thats all that really matters with the amount of continuity black holes in the franchise. The Doctor holds up a Cybermat. Why exactly did The Doctor use Teselecta to fake his own death? [2] This episode marks Lynda Baron's third involvement with Doctor Who, having provided vocals for the "Ballad of the Last Chance Saloon", heard in The Gunfighters (1966), and the role of Wrack in Enlightenment (1983). The Doctor and River escape to the top of the pyramid followed by Amy and Rory. [6] Their eyes are sunken within their sockets and the skin of their cheeks stretches to the point of their narrow chins. Why does River miss? Find a Doctor search results are also not based on the volume or value of referrals to Lifespan or its affiliates from any listed physician. However, we still own the copyright to them. We know, from having seen TIA before the Doctor has, how things are going to happen. Well we dont actually know if it is the Doctors body, despite what Canton says. Alfie's cries over the closed-circuit television echo in the ship. The Doctor tore along the shore of Silencio Lake; kicking up sand in his wake. He referred to the many concepts of the episode as a "sumptuous confection made mostly out of the finest ingredients" and found the Teselecta resolution a "cool twist" at first, but it meant "the whole episode is just an elaborate version of the classic Star Trek: Voyager alternate timeline shtick complete with reset button". He even has his Stetson. Craig, hearing Alfie, fights and reverses the conversion. Online. I do agree, that the recap part, that as soon as they described the Teselector, that was obviously the way out. Who Are The Silence In Doctor Who, Explained - MSN Still hatin on git: now with added Actual Reasons! [25], Patrick Mulkern, writing for Radio Times, thought that the ending was an "emotional overloadbut what better way to deal with the emotionally deprived Cybermen?" But extratextual reasons surely rule it out: we know that fourteen more episodes have been commissioned for 2012-2013, and that Smith, Gillan and Darvill have all been retained. [5] River Song states that she used her hallucinogenic lipstick on President Kennedy, a possession of hers that was introduced in "The Time of Angels". 24 Jun 2023 11:10:35 Id have to agree that the of course refers to River knowing the guns not loaded because the Doctor unloaded it. Aliens affiliated with The Silence seen to date in the series have been dressed in black business suits with an unusual texture. The whole Silence arc of Eleven's run (Cracks in Time, Lake Silencio, River Song, Siege of Trenzalore) happens because the Doctor saved Gallifrey. Something I always liked about Rory was his ability to not be so easily distracted by the Doctor's zany nature. And Oliver makes an excellent point about the diaryit never occurred to me that the reason River has to keep checking her diary is because her memories are so muddled by the Silence. Lake Silencio, Utah : r/doctorwho - Reddit We know from the end of Closing Time that the Doctor is off to Lake Silencio to enact the events of The Impossible Astronaut. This power is enhanced and becomes more destructive if they combine their energy and use it together. But I dont think that can be right, as we have followed Amy and Rorys timeline pretty constantly through the series. So tomorrow night sees the final episode in Series 6. US citizen, with a clean record, needs license for armored car with 3 inch cannon. His willingness to call out the Doctor's reckless, disrespectful, and occasional psychopathic traits made Rory a very strong character. The Doctor's future is River's past and The Doctor's past is River's future. One of the last episodes to be filmed for the series, production for "The Wedding of River Song" finished in April 2011. [5], Cybermats are shown for the first time in the revived series. And if it was a Ganger, how could it regenerate? River Song's story technically began in 2010's The Eleventh Hour, when the Doctor invited the feisty Amy Pond aboard his TARDIS. Lake Silencio was located in Utah, situated on the Plain of Sighs. How did he accomplish that without actually being injured and regenerating? So, considering all the armoring theyve put on the Impossible Astronaut, Id figured River had hit with all her shots, but that there was simply no effect on the souped up astronaut suit. Join. River later visits Amy and Rory to tell them the Doctor is still alive. And then it got rebooted. Because having three Doctors is like him, and his Schrdingers future might cause the timey-wimey-ness/messed-up time/Silence. No longer do your prints have to be just stuck to the wall and be left to get tatty and torn. [8] The four-fingered hands of the Silence, with one finger much longer than the other, were inspired by the aye-aye lemur.[8]. In promo pics we see River, Rory, and Amy with an eyepatch on. My best guess? Maybe she has a bad memory? (Anything that recalls Buffy is a plus for me. The Doctor leaves in the TARDIS to face his death. Their first attempt to stop the Doctor's arrival there is revealed to be the destruction of his TARDIS in Series 5. However, he did not think it was as good as "The Lodger" and thought the Cybermen were "wasted", citing the conclusion of Craig blowing them up with love as "unsatisfactory". Hes arrived just in time to see . Though he thought the Cyberman lacked "real menace" and Craig escaped in a "cheesy way", he considered the main focus to be on the Doctor's "farewell tour" and praised Smith's performance. Created Mar 12, 2008. [3] It shows Area 52 with the clock stuck at 5:02p.m., where the leaders of the religious order the Silence are kept in stasis and River Song is wearing an eye patch in the same fashion as Madame Kovarian.[4]. * If River knew what was going to happen, wouldnt she have realised when they were syncing diaries in the diner, and quipping about Jim the Fish? Hidden in plain sight. I fully expected the ganger Doctor to perish by the lake. [3] The Doctor takes the blue envelopes he uses to summon his companions from Craig's flat and Craig gives him the Stetson he wears at the start of "The Impossible Astronaut". I doubt it somehow but Moffats given us lots of options. So how did the universe not know that the doctor didnt actually die? Its OK, I know its you. Summary: As the Doctor prepares for his inevitable death at Lake Silencio, he visits a former roommate and learns that the Cybermen are responsible for a series of disappearances at a local department store and resolves to investigate. We did everything. and thus might have expected a regeneration as well, thus they considered this just another regeneration which they had to interrrupt, I don't think this question is a duplicate despite the almost identical title: The other one asks about why (or rather. Dan Martin of The Guardian questioned the decision to air a standalone episode as the penultimate show of the series, calling "Closing Time" "something of a curiosity" as well as writing positively about Smith and Corden's "Laurel and Hardy act". @1:38 Amy: He said hed be in touch. / Rory: Two months ago. / Amy: Two months is nothing, hes up to something, I know he is. This exchange suggests that from Amy and Rorys perspective, The Impossible Astronaut takes place after the Doctor drops them off at their house at the end of The God Complex. After only 7 minutes and 31 seconds of the first episode of the show's brand-new season, Moffatt killed off the Doctor. TV: Closing Time, The Wedding of River Song A prelude to the finale was released online 24 September 2011 after the previous episode, "Closing Time". Dr. Vincenzo Cilenti (Lazio) - amci.org [9] Originally, the script did not include the brief scene with a Dalek;[9] Moffat had intended to rest the Doctor's most famous adversary for the sixth series. Does the universe end or does the silence fall when the question is asked? The whole project. I suppose you could somehow fake it. 4. The Kovarian Chapter of the Silence used one such point in space-time 5:02 PM on 22 April 2011 by Lake Silencio to make the Eleventh Doctor's supposed death there a fixed point. even a motorbike!". I assumed Canton got his information from the Doctor inside the invitation. Elsewhere, the Doctor explains to Dorium that the Doctor's perceived death will enable him to withdraw and be forgotten, as he was getting too much attention. Weird one this. Faster than Ive ever run. I do want to put out there the idea that the eyepatch allows the wearer to remember the silence. The very same thing wed just left behind 12 hours earlier. Off we go. Of course we know that the Silents are associated with Madame Kovarian, because there are two of them with her at the end of Closing Time when the newly Ph.Dd River is put into the spacesuit. [28] Andrew Blair of Den of Geek defended the Cybermen in the episode, opining that the episode brought out the tragedy of them barely surviving and having to convert people mechanically without any emotional understanding of the situation. On your idea that the Question was asked in that unheard fifteen-second conversation I dont think so. In this case of the Silence, their existence is a secret because anyone who sees them immediately forgets about them after looking away, but retains suggestions made to them by the Silence. But if it was a Ganger would it dissolve into a puddle? document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. [9] Alan Sepinwall of HitFix wrote that though the Silence's central gimmick felt similar to previous ones, Moffat "continues to use those same tricks in such clever combinations, and with such technical flair, that I'm not tired of most of them yet. And youd want to burn a Gangers body to disguise that fact wouldnt you? The Doctor has spent a lot of time saying goodby this season. Why didnt the Doctor give Rose some regeneration energy? Roberts wanted the audience to think that maybe Craig would really be converted. When The Doctor is shot by the astronaut at Lake Silencio, he begins to regenerate, before being shot again and killed. [9] Charlie Jane Anders writing for io9 described it as a "worthy sequel" and "welcome shot of comedy" and was positive towards the "sweet" exploration of the Doctor's self-loathing that proved the universe needed him. Though the phrase "Silence will fall" recurred throughout the 2010 series of Doctor Who, the Silence were not seen until the 2011 series' opener "The Impossible Astronaut". However, we now know that this incarnation of the Doctor was the last Doctor of this cycle (the thirteenth regeneration), and he didnt have a new set yet. [10] Roberts felt that the episode's depiction of the Cybermen put it on the "silly/terrifying axis" that was common in Doctor Who. This is one loaded post, with no way for me to respond to every excellent point made (and oh, how I could, if it werent for that drasted posting limit), so Im going to go with the one that sticks out to me the most. It's April 22, 2011 the day the Doctor is supposed to die but time seems to be stuck at 5:02 p.m. London streets are clogged not only with automobiles but also Roman chariots; pterodactyls fly in the sky. I wonder whether much will hang on the silence/silents homophone. Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. [2] In the classic series, they appeared in The Tomb of the Cybermen (1967), The Wheel in Space (1968), and Revenge of the Cybermen (1975). I noticed this Season provided atleast 3 ways for the doctor to get out of it. Thank the gods for iPlayer). [2] A prequel, entitled "Up All Night", is included as part of the Night and the Doctor series of mini-episodes in the Series 6 DVD package. Lots of interesting thought here, thanks to everyone whos speculating! It was the real Doctor, he is dead, and his body is destroyed. While visual elements were praised, the characters and resolution of the episode received a mixed reception. [7][9] The Doctor frequently refers to Amy as "the girl who waited". The events at Lake Silencio are a fixed point in time, and must play out. @10:01 they cremate the Doctors body. She is kidnapped as a baby, in "A Good Man Goes to War", by Madame Kovarian (Frances Barber) in order to become a weapon against the Doctorher Time Lord-like genetic traits make her an ideal candidate to kill the Doctor. anneris31, it makes sense that River would shoot at herself because she doesnt remember being that younger self; but then it would make no sense for her to say of course not. [5], Writer Gareth Roberts said in an interview that he was considering bringing the character of Craig back when he saw James Corden's performance in "The Lodger", saying that "it already felt like he was one of the Who family". Memorable moment [3] Showrunner Steven Moffat was pleased with "The Lodger", an episode he called "quite close to my heart", and wanted to bring Craig back. What if the one who dies is the one who was poisoned. @Mike, ah, thats right so long ago that Id completely forgotten! Russell became the script editor for the revived series in 2005. (TV: The Wedding of River Song), River Song was abducted by the Silence and Kovarian, placed in an Apollo spacesuit and submerged in the lake to await the Eleventh Doctor. It is revealed that he had already planned escape by posing as himself using the shape-shifting Teselecta. (As she stands up to do so, she looks resigned more than sad or angry.) (TV: Closing Time), On 22 April 2011, the Doctor brought his companions to the lake for a picnic. So either she knows she hasnt really killed him, she did kill him but knows he survives, or she really is a psychopath. Its tenuous, I know. It seemed to me that River began firing at herself in the suit because she simply didnt remember that she did it. While absorbing and discharging this energy, a hole appears where one would expect a mouth to be. ( TV: The Wedding of River Song ) History Reddit's Doctor Who Fan Community - News, Discussion, Artwork and Fan Creations! Interesting episode. Not that that contributes anything to an explanation for the end of this season, but itd be an awesome (and Moffatt-like) teaser to what might happen next season. I mean, not really die. Awakened by the Doctor's presence, the Silence escape their cells and attack the troops defending the pyramid. Going one step further, is it possible the Doctor met his younger self in the diner before anybody else, and explained what was going to happen. @6:50 a decidedly careworn Doctor speaks to the astronaut. [23], The episode received mostly positive reviews from critics, with some reservations over the resolution and character interactions. It was written by Gareth Roberts and directed by Steve Hughes. Several dummies were used as well. As the Doctor is predestined to answer the question (which turns out to be the show's name itself, "Doctor who? Utah ", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Silence_(Doctor_Who)&oldid=1160435671, Short description is different from Wikidata, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 4.0, This page was last edited on 16 June 2023, at 12:58. The Silence are a religious order [1] in the British science fiction television programme Doctor Who, represented by humanoids with alien-like physical characteristics. [6] Amy's office contains the model of the TARDIS she made as a child ("The Eleventh Hour"), along with drawings of various monsters and scenes from her adventures with the Doctor. Ok, I changed my mind, here I am. My problem is the time loop-y part with Amy and Rory. Browse other questions tagged, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site. [32] Maureen Ryan of TV Squad criticised the episode for having too many "bells and whistles" which undermined the emotional moments, especially the wedding, which she did not believe showed that the Doctor was really in love with River. [5][6] When River meets Amy for a bottle of wine, she is wearing military fatigues and says that she "just climbed out of the Byzantium", and that she saw Amy there. Ill throw out a No worthy of Lord Vader if this is the case. To avoid crossing his own time stream, the Doctor gives the Teselecta crew four invitations to Lake Silencio in 2011 for Amy and Rory, River, Canton Everett Delaware III, and a younger version of himself. "The Wedding of River Song" concludes the story arc of the series and reveals what really happened at the start of the season premiere, "The Impossible Astronaut".
